and more...

Icons
Fiction
Video Recommendations
Links and Affiliates

rsbanner
The Creative Junkyard
Vidding Awards



Tragic Heroes

comments from streaming sites, forums and private feedback


egg0721
this is amazing. the songs you choose are always perfect!!!!! 5* is simply not enough. *two thumbs up*

castor
I always have trouble expressing myself when I see work this good. I usually just ramble, so I'll just say you're a genius. 'Tragic Heroes' is like a masterpiece & Carnivale is a nightmare. I've never seen the show, but just watching 'Creatures of Light and Dark' was too much for me.

darkhuntressamanda
I flippin love you, you combined everyone one of my fave heroes of all time in to one video there for you have my upmost respect... Thank you very much!!! FAVED PLAYLISTED 5/5 but you should get soooooooo much more!!

AJ
That was a great video man. Great song choice and I really liked how the intensity of the actions/expressions increased with the song in the final minute. I don't know the backstories of the characters but the video makes me want to check out the shows. You know I'm all about darkness lol. I have trouble expressing myself also when it comes to making comments about great pieces of work. I wanted to say so much more about that video but I'm not familiar with the fandoms and all.

humansrsuperior
So, I haven't seen any of the shows in this vid but DW, lol, but I've heard about this vid since you first started and I've been waiting for it! And it's totally awesome! As I knew it would be. It gave me chills; so much dark...tragedy LOL!

meivocis
Wow. I'm usually not a fan of mixed fandom vids but this is fantastic, and your editing is stunning.

absrip
I never would have thought to put these four characters together but that's what so great about diversity, others can think up so many great things that you yourself don't*g* It felt very painful to watch with the theme being as bleak as it is. I haven't watched Doctor Who, but I'm amazed by how effortless you managed to blend all four show together, it was beautiful and very cleanly done. You really draw a lot of great parallels between them all. Like with the fire clips at 0.43-48, or the blue at 2.07-2.10, the clips of Angel kicking in the door mirrored by Dean doing the same in the next clip. I love the image of the Docter standing in the fire at 2.20 which cuts to Dean firing the gun. You do so much without using any effects at all, this is pure great editing. I can see how people can recognize your vids, you really seem have a very certain style:) Yet again a very professional cut vid, I definitely understands why Thandie recced this!! Thanks a lot for sharing this it was beautiful and so sad.

counteragent
stunning editing! It's tough to blend newwho with these darker shows, but you did a great job with it.

kuwdora
DAMN. That's absolutely AMAZING.

summerpresson
this is so powerful !! it gave me chills !! favorited and subscribed !!

Shell
Another awesome vid from you. I'm a fan of Angel/Carnivale/Supernatural, not so much Doctor Who, but I love the parallels between them all, and how similar they are. I loved the voiceovers, particularly Dean\'s one which seemed to sum up the whole thing in a way

DisturbingKid
Brilliant as always. Somehow you always find the right music and scenes to use. Keep it up :)

Dualbunny
Wonderful!

stabbim
Wow, what a great vid! Tragic heroes indeed. Loved the mood the vid conveyed. Thank you for sharing!

Charmax
Brilliant as usual.

vyperman7
I loved it. I am a fan of all the shows you used except for Doctor Who simply because I have never seen it. But this was truly a fantastic piece of work. Great use of all shows, and I liked the parallels that you drew through out the video. I love it when people group similar things together. For example, I really liked when you showed Angel kicking in the door, and followed it up with Dean doing it. Great lyrical matching through out as well. I liked your effects in general. They were not overused, and when you decided to do a split or an overlay it was justified. I thought the overlay @ 3:13 was really fantastic. From 3:13- the end was my favorite section as a whole. I felt like it had the best energy and rythm and the scenes combined with that part of the song just had me totally sucked in. The song worked really well overall too. What I really liked about the video overall was the pacing. It never felt like anything lingered, and it didn't feel rushed either. Great video Reese.

Serenity113
Well it's about time. LOL. :D Share the world the awesomeness that is of this video. :P

camileb
beautifully done. which song did you used?

DarkestBeforeDawn2
Great video! I love the clips you used and the song is brilliant.

KirkesHeir
Beautiful...just beautiful. I don't know this "Ben" guy but that show looks like it's worth a try. Thanks for puttig three of my favorite male tv chars in one vid (especially the Doctor). Great song, great choice of scenes: the whole thing gave me goosebumps. The "tortured souls" are always the hottest guys, aren't they?

Ashley
wow you really capture the essence of all four characters the quality was amazing the editing was brillant love this video just as much as the angel trailer

LizzyQ16
Awesomeness...love the tenth doctor and dean of course..who sings?

PokeRevolution
amazing. thisis the 3rdreason ive hadtoday to sub to you. Well done, whats the song?

lena2347
what is the name of this song? Great video!!!

benofie
four of my favorite men! How perfect!! That has to be the prettiest video EVER! LOL! But seriously, excellent work

Clemontine
I have only watched Angel before. I am familiar with Supernatural and Doctor Who, but know nothing about Carnivale. But it was still an excellent video. The song created a great mood and the clip were perfect. Makes me wanna check out Carnivale as well.

DargorV
Insanely awesome tribute

NicoAngelus
This was amazing. Great editing. I don't even watch Supernatural, and I loved it. I would love to see another of this tragic heroes video, including Buffy Summers, and Sydney Bristow, or Sam Beckett...

Fandomoverload
damn that rocked it deserved another comment cause damn it's just awesome.

WickedWinifredBee
Absolutely AMAZING! I've never watched Doctor Who (too many seasons) but I love Ben, Angel (I'm actually watching my Angel dvds right now), and Dean. Thanks for posting. Favorited.

Chamalla01
Nice tribute to them all and more than excellent editing! And I absolutely love the song!

MamaHalblang
Wow! Just wow! Great song, great editing, great job. So wonderful intense...

sammylein17
i don“t know angel and ben but this song fits the doctor and dean very good^^

Louvonbeetoven
You know when I first saw the collaboration I was a bit skeptical, but now I think that's a really great ensemble of characters....very interesting.

Rachciah
I love Rob Dougan and from all the shows i don't watch only supernatural so i must love it. Great editing. Great heroes :)

ElaLemke
The editing for this video is impeccable! Wow!

philly7132812
Angel was off worse than anyone else, but either way this is an awesome video. Fav! and 5 stars.

saranwinter
Favorited!!! And will be recommended. Damn, great skills with the editing, and the choice of characters included.

snakegirl46
Love Carnivale and Supernatural. Im Okay with Angel and BTVS and havent watched Dr who or Tenth Dr(???). Love LOve LOVE this video and the music. You did a very, very Great Job. Seriously. Thank you so much for sharing.

jenlight
That was fantastic!

cassiebella314
Wow. Good Job!!

Nanceh89
This was an amazing video. Congrats on the Editing :)

1eva23
so due to this video I have decided to watch Carnivale. I have never even heard of it before, but i am a huge Angel/Doctor Who fan, and it seems very interesting. I love tv shows with a supernatural/fantasy twist to them, so I am always on the look out for something new. Thank you, and fantastic video!